NOMA - Non Overlapping Magisteria
CAN RELIGION AND SCIENCE ALIGN? -
THE NOMA QUESTION
If you're like me you might constantly battle with religion's supposed "inconsistency" with the real world. What you see around, what scientists may say and things you've deduced about the world by your own experiences may make you doubt if a supreme being exists. And in your heart you might truly want to believe but you just need evidence. You say to yourself, "if there's just proof beyond reasonable doubt that God is real, I'll serve him with all my heart and soul and mind", won't we all?I'm sorry to burst your bubble but if that's your reasoning, it's not happening. There's never going to be some gargantuan discovery that clears all doubt on if there's a creator or humanity is just a product of some extremely bizarre and one time matter combination. It's just not going to happen. So if you want to be religious, you going to have to do it with faith, you simply have to choose to believe.
Most of us do believe there's some sort of war going on between religion and science where they both hold different and irreconcilable beliefs about everything, or at least, most things. But a man named Stephen Jay Gould believes differently.
Gould is a renowned Historian, Professor and Biologist who believes in the principle of Non - Overlapping Magisteria (NOMA). This is a principle that believes that Religion and Science cannot conflict because they deal with totally different aspects of life and so they do not touch on the same subjects. In his opinion a man can believe totally in science and still be totally religious because science and religion preside over different "Magisterias"/ teaching authorities, so their principles cannot clash. According to him - "To cite the arch clichés, we get the age of rocks, and religion retains the rock of ages; we (science) study how the heavens go, and they determine how to go to heaven"
I stumbled upon this philosophy when I was researching a book my atheist friend Derek told me about. It was "The God delusion" by Richard Dawkins. Dawkins is completely atheist although he points to being a little agnostic by saying "only to the extent that I am agnostic about the existence of fairies at the bottom of the garden". Dawkins criticizes Gould on NOMA propagation and believes he's being completely unrealistic as religion and science usually conflict on many subjects. Both Theists and Atheists have criticized Gould on NOMA, some saying he's simply being a religious apologist and some scorn him for trying to be a diplomat for two sides that need no reconciliation.
Gould paints religion and science as having no conflict because they touch on exclusively different matters. According to NOMA, Science touches on empirical evidence of how the world works using the scientific method while religion dictates morals and how to live. Gould says only Theists that take religious texts literally would reject this explanation because religious texts are literary works and like every other great literary work require interpretation to be properly understood. He says most religious texts do support science when they're properly interpreted.
In Gould's essay he points to the Catholic church's progressively accepting NOMA. I was actually shocked to discover from Gould's essay that the Catholic Church actually accommodates studying the Theory of Evolution (either for favor or opposition) In the 1950 encyclical Humani generis by Pope Pius XII, on the grounds that all Catholics must accept that individual soul was directly created by God if they want to be evolutionists. This sort of admission by a religious body as huge as the Catholic Church is certainly a score for NOMA.
Einstein was also an advocate of NOMA as we can deduce that from his 1954 essay "Science and religion". Einstein believed that science and religion actually complemented each other, he says; “Science without religion is lame, religion without science is blind.”
He described science as what 'is' (physical and observable facts) and religion as what 'ought' (morals).
Quoting Einstein: "A conflict arises when a religious community insists on the absolute truthfulness of all statements recorded in the Bible. This means an intervention on the part of religion into the sphere of science; this is where the struggle of the Church against the doctrines of Galileo and Darwin belongs. On the other hand, representatives of science have often made attempts to arrive at fundamental judgments about values and ends on the basis of scientific method, and in this way have set themselves in opposition to religion. These conflicts have all sprung from fatal errors". Even though Einstein's and Gould's views are so similar, Gould never mention or quotes Einstein in his essay.
He described science as what 'is' (physical and observable facts) and religion as what 'ought' (morals).
Quoting Einstein: "A conflict arises when a religious community insists on the absolute truthfulness of all statements recorded in the Bible. This means an intervention on the part of religion into the sphere of science; this is where the struggle of the Church against the doctrines of Galileo and Darwin belongs. On the other hand, representatives of science have often made attempts to arrive at fundamental judgments about values and ends on the basis of scientific method, and in this way have set themselves in opposition to religion. These conflicts have all sprung from fatal errors". Even though Einstein's and Gould's views are so similar, Gould never mention or quotes Einstein in his essay.
At this point it might start to add up and you might start to think that it's possible for these two areas not to go hand in hand until you look at the historical proof where religion has repeatedly infiltrated the magisteria of science and science that of religion.
One of the more popular example is that of Galileo and heliocentrism. Heliocentrism is the belief (now fact) that the sun is the centre of the universe and that the earth revolves around it in opposition to a former belief in geocentrism - that the earth was the centre of the universe.
The heliocentric theory was initially published by Copernicus in 1543. Copernicus had to publish his book when he was already dying, because he knew that he would incur the wrath of the Catholic Church who at the time held strongly to geocentrism. At least they couldn't punish him while he was already in hell or heaven.
Galileo was the inventor of the telescope and with it he viewed the planetary bodies. He was the first to discover that the moon was not smooth but was like a mountain and pitted. The research he conducted with his Telescope led him to increasingly believe in the heliocentric theory. Shortly after he started publishing his papers he was forced to revoke any evidence that he was proving Corpenicus' theory in 1633 by the Catholic Church to avoid meeting the same fate as his colleague Giordano Bruno, who burnt on the Stakes in 1600 for Heresy. Legend has it that even after retracting his claims, during his trial Galileo still muttered under his voice,"Eppur si muove"- and yet it moves.
It wasn't until 1992, 359 years after Galileo's persecution, that the Catholic Church in a public declaration by Pope John Paul II admits that it was wrong and Galileo was right.
This is a clear historical intrusion of religion on the magisteria of science.
There have also been many intrusions of science on the magisteria of religion. An example being Dawkins in his book "The Selfish genes" trying to explain that human empathy doesn't come from a soul or God, but is naturally caused by "altruistic genes". This means we're naturally wired to be empathetic towards those with similar genetic makeup as us. He says the more similar the genes are, the more empathic we will be towards that person. This is trying to explain natural empathy and morals which according to the principle of NOMA is under the magisteria of Religion.
In the end it's clear that NOMA can only work if you're ready to adhere to a certain definition of religion, similar to the one Gould and Einstein adopt. And the reason these people sit so comfortably on those kinds of definitions is because they do not have a traditional view/philosophy on religion. Gould is agnostic and Einstein is a Pantheist; A person that believes nature and the universe to be God/God's expression, "God is everything and everything is God". You may not accept this because of your own theistic view. For the majority, religion not only covers how to live morally but also how to work to fulfil a divine destiny, how to pray and obtain favours from God, how to avoid burning in a lake of fire for eternity and a full discourse on what happens after death, if this is you then religion is certainly so much more than morals you. There are also those who do not think religion or God is the cause of morality. For both groups, NOMA can't apply.
Conclusively, I'll have to say that despite how alluring it may sound, NOMA can only be accepted by a small section of people, even I have objections. What's your opinion? Let me know in the comment section below
Ciao.
Make sure to follow by email (the option is on the side bar; top right corner) so you'll be notified when I put up any new content. Also, if you want to see me write about any related topic just comment below.
I'll really appreciate it.
5 comments
Nice writeup
ReplyA+
ReplyMan. You are great amongst the stars and firmaments. Sounds a bit Misotheist, only a teeeny tiny bit, but fucking epic write up
ReplyNice write up but how can one reconcile religion with science on issues such as gender disparities that's clearly both a moral and scientific issue
ReplyInteresting article
Reply